I am more convinced than ever that instant replay would be bad for baseball.
Not surprisingly, the Anchoress gets it right, but I want to add one other observation. Many people argue that if the technology gives us the power to get calls right, to fix wrongs, we have an obligation to use it.
In my universe, watching the implementation of replay review in football and hockey, the technology gives us no such power. Here is the result of replay reviews in my world:
20% fix a bad call
20% confirm the call was already right.
20% confirm the call was wrong but it doesn’t get fixed because the ref says “inconclusive”
20% generates disagreement and controversy among fans and announcers as to whether the call should be overturned
20% the review ref makes a decision that is universally thought to be wrong
How is this better, especially with the wasted time?
Really, is your experience different? Why do people imagine we can just fix the bad ones?

